| Home \ Away | MU | MSU | NKU | TNU | UCA | UK | UTM |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mercyhurst | 16-14 15-10 | 22-0 | — | — | — | 10-13 12-16 | |
| MO State | 11-20 | — | — | 9-10 21-0 | 3-23 | — | |
| N Kentucky | 1-18 0-22 | 0-22 0-21 | — | 2-20 | — | — | |
| Trevecca | 11-3 | 19-5 | 22-0 23-0 | 19-3 | — | — | |
| Cent Arkansas | 5-19 | 7-8 | — | — | 0-24 | — | |
| Kentucky | 23-0 24-0 | — | 23-0 | 23-2 23-5 23-4 | — | 24-0 | |
| UT Martin | — | 15-12 | 22-0 | 6-21 12-20 4-18 | 16-7 23-1 24-0 | — |